Payroll compliance in schools: Are you paying the right amount?
By Megan Kavanagh and Victoria Lekkas
Complex enterprise agreements, varied working arrangements and diverse employee groups can make schools particularly vulnerable to payroll errors. In this article, we look at where those risks commonly arise and seven key questions school leaders should be asking.
In brief
Schools are complex workplaces, with teachers, teacher aides, administration employees, boarding staff, grounds staff, coaches and casual employees often working under different enterprise agreements, awards and contractual arrangements.
This complexity increases the risk of payroll errors and non-compliance.
The greatest risk is not necessarily that payroll makes a calculation error. It is that payroll is applying the wrong rule.
An employee may be incorrectly classified. An allowance may have been missed. Additional responsibilities may trigger higher duties. Work performed outside ordinary hours, including camps, excursions, sporting activities, boarding duties or compulsory training, may have payroll consequences that have not been recognised.
Once an incorrect assumption is embedded in the system, the same mistake can be repeated every pay cycle.
A payroll system can calculate the wrong answer perfectly, every time.
What are the compliance and governance implications?
Payroll compliance is increasingly considered a governance issue, not simply an administrative one.
Since 1 January 2025, intentional underpayment of wages can constitute a criminal offence. An ordinary payroll error is not automatically wage theft, but schools may still face back-pay liabilities, civil penalties, superannuation consequences, interest, remediation costs and regulatory scrutiny.
The risks can also become systemic. A mistake affecting one employee may indicate that the same incorrect classification, allowance or payroll rule has been applied to an entire employee cohort.
Where are the risks for schools?
- Classification: Are employees classified according to the work they perform, particularly where roles have evolved or additional responsibilities have been assumed?
- Working time: Are schools accurately capturing work that occurs outside ordinary hours, including meetings, training, camps, excursions, sporting and co-curricular activities?
- Allowances and higher duties: Is there a reliable process for communicating changes in an employee's duties to payroll?
- Annual salaries: Paying an employee above the relevant award rate does not necessarily eliminate underpayment risk. Recent case law involving Woolworths and Coles reinforces the importance of testing whether underlying entitlements have been satisfied in the relevant pay period.
- Enterprise agreements: Has payroll configuration kept pace with changes made through successive bargaining rounds, including changes to classifications, allowances, hours and overtime?
What should schools be doing?
Rather than waiting for an employee complaint, schools should periodically test payroll against the underlying industrial instruments.
A practical review should ask:
- Coverage: Do we know which award or enterprise agreement applies to each employee group?
- Classification: Do classifications still reflect the work employees perform?
- Working time: Are relevant hours being accurately captured?
- Allowances: Are changes in duties reliably communicated to payroll?
- Salaries: Have annual salary and set-off arrangements been reviewed against current requirements?
- Change management: Who is responsible for ensuring changes to awards, enterprise agreements and legislation reach payroll?
- Assurance: When was payroll last independently tested against the underlying legal obligations?
From payroll issue to governance issue
School boards and leadership teams do not need to administer payroll. They should, however, have confidence that appropriate systems are in place to identify errors before they become systemic.
The question for school leaders is therefore no longer simply:
"Did payroll run successfully?"
It is:
"How do we know our people have been paid correctly?"
For schools, that distinction matters. The aim of good payroll governance is not to guarantee that an error will never occur. It is to have systems capable of finding a small error before it becomes a large one.
Conclusion
If you would like to discuss any of the payroll compliance issues raised in this article or understand the implications for your school, please contact a member of our Education team.