Reasonable adjustment: Supporting inclusion and balancing safety
By Megan Kavanagh and Lucille Day
Balancing the rights of students with disability to participate fully in education with the safety and wellbeing of the broader school community requires careful consideration. Effective consultation, reasonable adjustments and regular review are critical to achieving safe, inclusive and meaningful participation.
In brief
Ensuring the safe and supportive inclusion of students with disability is a fundamental goal for schools and other child-facing organisations. It is also required by law.
Achieving both inclusion and safety is not always straightforward, particularly where a student’s needs or behaviour affect staff, other students or the learning environment. We are seeing that tension in the statistics. In 2023–24, education accounted for 11% of complaints made under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth).
Schools and child-facing organisations want to get this right. However, doing so requires a considered and holistic approach, meaningful consultation, careful standard setting, objective assessment of issues, effective implementation of supports, balanced input from allied health and regular review.
What is a reasonable adjustment?
Under the Disability Standards for Education 2005 (Cth), schools must make reasonable adjustments where necessary to enable students with disability to participate in education on the same basis as students without disability.
An adjustment recommended by a parent, treating practitioner or specialist is an important starting point, but it does not determine what is legally reasonable. A school must consider all relevant circumstances, including:
- the student’s disability and individual needs;
- the views of the student and their family;
- relevant medical or specialist advice;
- whether the adjustment is likely to be effective;
- its effect on the student’s learning, participation and dignity;
- its effect on staff, other students and the learning environment;
- its practical and financial implications; and
- any risks to physical or psychological health and safety.
The question is not only whether an adjustment would benefit the student. It is whether the adjustment is reasonable in the particular circumstances, having regard to the interests of everyone affected.
Responding to disability-related behaviour
The assessment can become more difficult where behaviour associated with a student’s disability creates safety or educational concerns. The connection between disability and behaviour is important. It may identify unmet needs, environmental triggers or additional supports that could reduce the behaviour and support the student’s continued participation.
However, a disability-related explanation does not mean a school must accept behaviour that creates an unacceptable risk of injury, psychological harm or serious disruption to learning. In such cases, schools should consider:
- the nature, frequency and seriousness of the behaviour;
- its relationship to the student’s disability;
- known triggers and warning signs;
- the adjustments and supports already in place;
- whether those adjustments have been implemented consistently and the effects that they produce;
- whether further or different adjustments may be effective;
- whether the risk can be managed through additional controls; and
- relevant allied health recommendations, including independent assessments.
The focus should be on understanding and managing the behaviour, rather than attributing blame to the student.
What does Purvis tell us?
Purvis v New South Wales (Department of Education and Training) [2003] HCA 62 is the case often cited in support of the suggestion that poor conduct by any student, irrespective of disability, can support a significant discipline response.
However, as Purvis predates the Disability Standards for Education, it has to be understood in the context of those Standards. The requirement to ensure consultation, considered reasonable adjustments and assessment of the interests of all affected parties sits alongside Purvis and means that schools or child-facing organisations need to demonstrate consultation and supports regarding conduct and behaviour before enrolment, during enrolment and prior to difficult decisions being made.
Purvis illustrates that a disability-related explanation for behaviour does not remove the legitimate interests of staff and other students in safety. However, the case should not be read as suggesting that exclusion is the inevitable response to disability-related behaviour. The contemporary framework requires schools to consider reasonable adjustments, consultation and whether risks can be appropriately managed.
Purvis and the Standards do not require the school to disregard serious risks to staff, other students or the learning environment. However, if the school cannot demonstrate clear consultation, serious reflection and consideration around adjustment before a decision is made, it may fall into error.
Integrating inclusion and safety
Consultation is essential not only to meet inclusion obligations under the Standards and disability legislation, but also to fulfil work health and safety obligations and protect the wellbeing of people in schools.
Under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) and in other states, risks must be eliminated so far as reasonably practicable or, if elimination is not reasonably practicable, minimised so far as reasonably practicable. This does not mean that all behavioural risk must be eliminated before a student can participate. Risks may be managed through measures such as:
- additional supervision or staffing;
- environmental or timetable changes;
- specialist support;
- behaviour or safety plans;
- staff training; and
- changes to activities or transitions.
Where an immediate risk arises, interim protective measures may be necessary while the school consults and reassesses the student’s adjustments. Any interim measure should be proportionate, time-limited and regularly reviewed.
The objective is not to choose between inclusion and safety. It is to determine whether the student can participate safely with reasonable adjustments and appropriate controls.
Consultation and implementation
Consultation is not a single meeting or an administrative step. It is an ongoing process of communication. A school should consult the student and their family, consider relevant specialist advice, seek its own information, explain its concerns and genuinely explore available options. Consultation does not require the school to agree to every proposal.
If an adjustment cannot reasonably be implemented, the school should document:
- the purpose and anticipated benefit of the proposal;
- the information and views considered;
- its practical, educational and safety impacts;
- why it is not reasonable or effective; and
- the alternative adjustments considered.
Agreed adjustments must then be implemented consistently. Responsibilities should be clear; staff should receive appropriate information and training and the effectiveness of the arrangement should be monitored.
An adjustment may also need to change as the student’s needs, behaviour, learning environment or available information changes.
A practical framework
When disability-related needs or behaviour create safety or educational concerns, schools should:
- Identify the issue and consider the role of disability.
- Consult with the student and family and consider relevant specialist advice.
- Assess the risk: consider the likelihood and consequences of harm to the student, staff and others.
- Explore options and consider whether additional adjustments, environmental changes, staffing, supervision and other controls are required or necessary.
- Decide what is reasonable by assessing the interests of those affected.
- Document and communicate the process of consultation, the decision and the reasons for it.
- Implement and review reasonable supports to confirm whether existing adjustments have been adequately resourced and consistently applied.
- Monitor and review the adjustments, how staff are travelling with the supports and what they understand by them. As incidents occur or a student’s needs change, further consultation and information may be needed to inform further adjustments or other responses.
Getting the balance right
Ensuring the safe and inclusive participation of students with disability is a fundamental responsibility of schools and other child-facing organisations, as well as a legal obligation. Achieving both inclusion and safety is not always straightforward. Complaints data illustrates the continuing challenge, with complaints up 22% since 2019–20.
Schools will not always be able to prevent difficult incidents or achieve an arrangement that satisfies everyone. The law does, however, require a genuine, informed and continuing process directed towards safe and meaningful participation.
By consulting, considering the interests of all affected parties, implementing agreed adjustments and regularly reviewing their effectiveness, schools are better placed to support inclusion while protecting the safety and wellbeing of students and staff.
That is the central task of reasonable adjustment: supporting students with disability to participate in a safe, supportive and effective learning environment.
Conclusion
If your school is navigating complex disability inclusion or reasonable adjustment matters, particularly where student needs intersect with safety and wellbeing obligations, please contact a member of our Education team to discuss the issues raised in this article and how best to manage these challenges.