State steps in: Submitter appeal vacated pending proposed State facilitated development declaration
By Nadia Czachor, Krystal Cunningham-Foran and George Gardener
The Planning and Environment Court vacates the hearing dates for a submitter appeal pending the Minister's consideration of a State facilitated development declaration.
In brief
The case of Smith v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2026] QPEC 35 concerned a submitter appeal to the Planning and Environment Court of Queensland (Court) against the decision of the Brisbane City Council (Council) to approve a development application made by Zen Group (Co-Respondent). The development application is for a material change of use and building work for a multiple dwelling (176 units), community use, food and drink outlet, office and shop across two towers at 24 Duncan Street, West End (Proposed Development) (see [1] to [2]).
On 3 August 2026, an order was made listing the matter for a five day hearing commencing on 26 October 2026. The Co-Respondent subsequently advised the Court that the Minister for State Development, Infrastructure and Planning (Minister) was considering whether to declare the development application an application for State facilitated development under section 106D of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) (the Act) (at [8]).
The Co-Respondent sought orders to vacate the allocated hearing dates and remove the requirement for the parties to deliver trial material to the Court (at [10]). The Court exercised its discretion to grant the order as proposed by the Co-Respondent pending the outcome of the Minister's decision, and the Minister subsequently made the declaration.
Process for declaring State facilitated development
The Court considered the process for declaring a development application to be an application for State facilitated development having regard to section 106D of the Act which provides as follows:
"(1) The Minister may, within 10 business days after the day the representation
period ends, declare that the relevant application is an application for State
facilitated development.
(2) However, the Minister may make the declaration only if—
(a) the Minister considers that the carrying out of the development the subject of
the application will assist in delivering development that—
(i) is for an urban purpose; and
(ii) is an identified priority for the State; and
(b) the application complies with the criteria prescribed by regulation; and
(c) the Minister is satisfied it is appropriate for the chief executive to assess and
decide all or part of the application instead of the decision-maker for the
application.
(3) In considering the matter mentioned in subsection (2)(c), the Minister may have regard to any matter the Minister considers relevant.
(4) In this section—
urban purpose means a purpose for which land is used in cities and towns—
(a) including residential, industrial, sporting, recreational and commercial purposes; but
(b) not including rural residential, environmental, conservation, rural, natural or wilderness area purposes."
The declaration was required to be made between 17 October 2026 and 30 October 2026 which coincided with the allocated hearing dates. The Minister is required to give notice to the parties of the outcome of the decision in accordance with section 106E of the Act (at [18]).
If a State facilitated development declaration is made, any appeal against the decision of the original decision-maker is discontinued and will restart from the point outlined within the declaration notice, which in this case was the start of the public notification stage (see [21] to [22] and section 106H of the Act). Following a declaration from the Minister that a development application is for State facilitated development, the assessment and decision process under Chapter 3, Part 6A, Division 3 of the Act applies and the chief executive must assess and decide, or reassess and re-decide, the development application or part thereof as the case may be.
Court exercises its discretion to make the order
In deciding whether to make the orders, the Court considered its obligations under the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld) to facilitate the just and expeditious resolution of the issues whilst avoiding unnecessary delay and expense (at [24]).
A key consideration that favoured the granting of the order related to the potential waste of resources and time associated with the preparation of submissions and liaising with expert witnesses, only for the Minister to subsequently make the declaration (at [26]).
Against that consideration, the Court recognised that vacating the hearing dates could delay the ultimate determination of the appeal, potentially until the following year, if the Minister decided not to make the declaration (at [28]).
Conclusion
On balance, the Court was satisfied that the hearing dates should be vacated. In reaching that conclusion, the Court noted that little remained to be done if the matter ultimately proceeded to hearing and that experienced counsel would be capable of preparing for trial at short notice (at [29]).
Since the Court made the orders, the development application has been declared to be State facilitated development for reasons including that the Proposed Development will assist in delivering development that is for an urban purpose and is an identified priority of the State. The declaration notice was issued on 27 October 2026 with reference SFD-01167. Accordingly, the appeal against the Council's decision is discontinued by virtue of section 106H(2)(c) of the Act and the development application will now be assessed and decided under Chapter 3, Part 6A, Division 3 of the Act.
Key points
The Minister has powers under Chapter 3, Part 6A of the Act to declare a development application, proposed development application, change application or proposed change application for a material change of use or reconfiguring a lot (each a relevant application) as an application for State facilitated development.
The effect of such a declaration is significant for the following reasons:
- The Minister may make a declaration even if the relevant application has been decided by the decision-maker for the relevant application except if the relevant application has been decided by the Court or the relevant application is not substantially different from an application that has been decided by the Court (see section 106A of the Act).
- If the Minister makes a declaration that a relevant application is an application for State facilitated development, section 106H(2) of the Act provides as follows:
- Any decision on the relevant application made by the decision-maker, including any deemed approval, stops having effect.
- Any decision notice given by the decision-maker for the relevant application stops having effect.
- Any appeal against a decision on the relevant application made by the decision-maker is discontinued.
- If the declaration notice states the restarting point for the relevant application, the process for administering the relevant application starts again from the restarting point.
- Following a declaration by the Minister that a relevant application is for State facilitated development, the relevant application is to be assessed and decided by the chief executive under Chapter 3, Part 6A, Division 3 of the Act such that the usual development assessment provisions set out in section 106J(3) of the Act do not apply.
- The Act does not provide appeal rights to members of the public who make a submission in respect of the relevant application during public notification of the relevant application in the State facilitated development assessment process.
- The only avenue available to the public in respect of a decision by the chief executive for a relevant application is judicial review proceedings which, to be successful, require the establishment of specific errors or failures on the part of the chief executive in arriving at a decision in respect of the relevant application and do not permit a merits review of a decision made by the chief executive.