PUBLICATIONS circle 19 Nov 2026

When safeguarding creates risk: Managing the people impact of reportable conduct

By Megan Kavanagh and Zoe Jeffrey

Queensland’s Reportable Conduct Scheme can create psychosocial risks for employees involved in allegations and investigations. We outline practical steps schools can take to manage these risks while maintaining student safety and procedural fairness.


In brief

Queensland's Reportable Conduct Scheme (RCS) is intended to strengthen child safeguarding. However, since July, it has inadvertently created psychosocial risks for some employees who are the subject of allegations or investigations.

Schools must manage both the allegation and the psychological risks concurrently. While protecting students remains paramount, a fair, timely and proportionate process is also an important work health and safety control.

This is particularly important in a sector already experiencing significant workforce pressure. Research published by UNSW Sydney in 2025 reported very high levels of stress, depression and anxiety among teachers. Against this backdrop, the uncertainty, isolation and reputational concerns associated with a reportable conduct process may compound existing psychological risks.

What is a psychosocial hazard?

A psychosocial hazard arises from, or relates to, the design or management of work, the work environment, workplace interactions or behaviours and may cause psychological harm.

In schools, common psychosocial hazards include:

  • high workload and competing demands;
  • difficult parent or community interactions;
  • poor support or poor organisational justice; and
  • complaints, investigations and regulatory processes.

These hazards may cause stress. Prolonged or severe stress can cause psychological harm. A worker's perception that they are exposed to an ongoing and uncontrolled risk may itself contribute to stress, even where the employer considers that the underlying risk is being managed.

The introduction of the Reportable Conduct Scheme (RCS) may heighten concern among staff about mandatory notifications, the threshold for reporting, the use of reportable conduct language in complaints and the possible professional consequences of an allegation. Clear information about how the scheme operates is therefore an important risk control.

Psychosocial risks arising from a reportable conduct allegation

When an employee becomes the subject of an allegation, foreseeable psychosocial risks may include:

  • uncertainty about the process, timeframe and possible outcomes;
  • concern about professional reputation or registration;
  • loss of agency or control;
  • workplace isolation, rumours or speculation;
  • fear of suspension, stand-down or loss of duties; and
  • communications or conduct that imply guilt or predetermination before findings are made.

A statutory reporting obligation does not displace the employer's work health and safety duties. Schools should identify the hazards created or intensified by the reporting and investigation process, assess the associated risks, implement reasonably practicable controls and review whether those controls remain effective. The RCS expects that risk to staff will be managed along with risk to students.

So how can schools get ahead of these risks and prepare their workforces for the RCS process?

It is important that those involved in or the subject of complaints are appropriately supported and prepared for the process. Understanding the range of potential outcomes is an important part of preparedness. Of the 666 notifications received during the Scheme's first three months, we understand that more than 70% resulted in no further referral action, while fewer than 6% resulted in the suspension or cancellation of a Blue Card.

That reference point should provide some comfort that the process is not about 'gotcha' moments (other than for the most serious conduct). It is about support and improvement.

To make the most of that opportunity, schools might consider that, along with RCS training, they also prepare staff by:

1. Ensuring they understand the process and what is likely to occur before an allegation arises

Well-drafted complaints processes, child-safety and parent and student conduct policies can help staff set boundaries, escalate concerns and manage issues consistently before they develop into formal complaints. However, explaining what happens to a staff member and their rights and responsibilities in the process is often less clear in these processes.

Where knowledge is power, policies should explain how reportable conduct concerns are identified, notified, assessed and investigated and how the school will support everyone affected.

Training should reinforce that notification is not a finding of wrongdoing. Staff should understand the distinction between an allegation, a notification, an investigation and a substantiated finding, as well as the possible employment and regulatory outcomes.

2. Manage notification and investigation with care

The investigation process should be handled with a level of informality and support around notification to the staff member. The process should be timely, fair, clear and appropriately confidential. Practical supports might include:

  • Provide clear information
    (a) give written notice of the allegations, with sufficient particulars to enable a meaningful response;
    (b) explain the process, likely stages, indicative timeframe and possible outcomes; and
    (c) nominate one contact person and establish an agreed update schedule, including updates where there has been no substantive progress.

  • Enable a genuine response
    (a) allow reasonable time to prepare and respond;
    (b) provide access to relevant material, subject to any necessary protections; and
    (c) permit a support person and consider any reasonable adjustments required.

  • Maintain impartiality
    (a) appoint an investigator with appropriate expertise and manage any actual or perceived conflicts;
    (b) consider information that is both favourable and adverse to the employee; and
    (c) avoid language or conduct that suggests the outcome has been predetermined.

  • Protect confidentiality
    (a) information should be disclosed only on a need-to-know basis; and
    (b) witnesses and relevant staff should be reminded of confidentiality expectations, while recognising that absolute confidentiality cannot always be guaranteed. This protects the integrity of the investigation and helps manage risks to the employee, students and witnesses.

  • Communicate a reasoned outcome
    (a) the outcome should be communicated respectfully and with enough explanation to demonstrate that the employee's response was genuinely considered; and
    (b) unnecessary delay or unexplained silence can increase uncertainty, distress and speculation.

3. Use proportionate interim safeguards

A reportable conduct allegation does not automatically require suspension or stand-down. Interim measures should be based on a documented assessment of current risk, not the seriousness of the allegation alone. The school should consider student safety, the integrity of the investigation, the employee's contractual and industrial arrangements, any regulator or registration requirements and the psychosocial impact of the proposed control.

Where appropriate, risks may be managed through less restrictive controls, such as:

  • increased supervision;
  • modified duties or temporary relocation;
  • restricted contact with particular students;
  • restricted access to systems or records; and
  • temporary limits on participation in particular activities.

Interim measures should be documented, explained as risk controls rather than disciplinary findings, reviewed at defined intervals and adjusted when circumstances change. Suspension or stand-down may be appropriate where there is a current and material child-safety risk, a genuine risk to evidence or the investigation, lesser controls are inadequate and the applicable employment instrument permits the action.

4. Plan for outcome and reintegration

The completion of an investigation does not end the school's responsibility to manage psychosocial risk. Even where allegations are not substantiated, an employee may experience isolation, loss of trust, reputational concern or anxiety about returning to ordinary duties.

Before reintegration, the school should consider:

  • what the findings mean for the employee and whether any training, management action or disciplinary response is warranted;
  • whether restrictions remain necessary and, if not, how they can be removed promptly and with minimal disruption;
  • who needs to know the outcome and what can appropriately be communicated;
  • how rumours or speculation will be addressed while maintaining privacy;
  • what support the employee, relevant students, witnesses and managers require;
  • how concerns or loss of trust between the employee and relevant students will be managed; and
  • when the effectiveness of the reintegration plan will be reviewed.

A re-entry conversation should provide role clarity, confirm any continuing controls, identify supports and agree on regular check-ins. Access to an employee assistance program may form part of the response, but it should not replace active management of the workplace hazards.

Key takeaways

The RCS is an important child-safeguarding measure. However, the reporting and investigation process can also create foreseeable psychosocial risks for employees, including uncertainty, isolation, reputational concern and loss of control.

Schools should manage these risks through clear communication, fair and timely investigations, proportionate interim controls and carefully planned reintegration. This does not require schools to compromise student safety. Rather, it supports sound safeguarding decisions by ensuring allegations are managed consistently, objectively and with appropriate regard to everyone affected.

Conclusion

Colin Biggers & Paisley can assist schools with training on the Reportable Conduct Scheme, the design and review of relevant policies and procedures, risk assessment, employment advice and the conduct of independent investigations. Please contact our Education team if you would like to discuss how your school can prepare for and manage these issues.

This is commentary published by Colin Biggers & Paisley for general information purposes only. Cases referenced in this article are reported for information purposes only. Nothing in this article should be taken to imply that any referenced allegation is true or any finding final. This should not be relied on as specific advice. You should seek your own legal and other advice for any question, or for any specific situation or proposal, before making any final decision. The content also is subject to change. A person listed may not be admitted as a lawyer in all States and Territories. Colin Biggers & Paisley, Australia 2026

Stay connected

Connect with us to receive our latest insights.