All that glitters is not gold: Land Appeal Court clarifies mining use extends beyond extraction
By Nadia Czachor, Krystal Cunningham-Foran and Innes McDiarmid
A mining lease holder of rateable land in Charters Towers has been unsuccessful in arguing the land was incorrectly categorised for rates purposes as being used for a mine even though extraction has not occurred since circa 2015.
In brief
The case of Citigold Corporation Limited v Charters Towers Regional Council [2026] QLAC 10 (Citigold (Appeal)) concerned an appeal to the Land Appeal Court of Queensland (Land Appeal Court) in which it considered the construction of the definition of "mine" in the definitions of land rating categories within the 2023-2024 Revenue Statement (Revenue Statement) of the Charters Towers Regional Council (Council) relevant to the rating category for land in three areas of Charters Towers which comprise seven properties (Relevant Land) with 25 mining leases held by Citigold Corporation Limited (Appellant).
The case of Citigold Corporation Limited v Charters Towers Regional Council [2025] QLC 27 (Citigold (First Instance)) concerned an appeal to the Land Court of Queensland (Land Court) against the rating categorisation decision of the Council for the Relevant Land on grounds that the categorisation decision relied on an incorrect interpretation and application of categories in the Revenue Statement, and did not have regard to the characteristics, features and state of the Relevant Land (at [14] of Citigold (First Instance)).
The Land Court did not allow the appeal, and subsequently in the case of Citigold Corporation Limited v Charters Towers Regional Council (No 2) [2025] QLC 30 (Citigold (Costs)) made an order for costs against the Appellant after the Land Court found that the Appellant brought the appeal for its own commercial reasons and was unsuccessful, despite there being a minor matter of principle to be determined in the appeal. The Land Appeal Court confirmed the decisions of the Land Court and dismissed the Appellant's appeal.
Parties' positions as to the appropriate rating category
Historical mining of the Relevant Land ceased by 2015 at the latest, but the Appellant "aspires" to reopen the gold mining operations (see [1] to [4] of Citigold (First Instance) and [1] of Citigold (Appeal)).
For the 2023-24 rating year, the Council categorised each parcel of the Relevant Land as Category 20 (Other Mine/quarry or extractive land use - less than 25 employees and/or contractors) according to the rating categories in the Revenue Statement which relevantly applies to land which is a mining lease issued pursuant to the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld) (mining lease) with a rateable valuation above $14,999 which forms part of a mine with fewer than 25 employees and/or contractors.
The Appellant contended that the Relevant Land belonged in residual Category 21 (Other Mine/quarry or extractive land use (not falling within Category 16 to 20)), which relevantly applies to land which is a mining lease and does not fall into Categories 16 to 20 (see [6] and [13] of Citigold (First Instance)).
The Appellant objected to the categorisation and, following the review decision of the chief executive officer of the Council not to allow the objection, appealed to the Land Court under section 92 of the Local Government Regulation 2012 (Qld) (LGR). The Land Court's powers under section 93 of the LGR include changing the rating category or not allowing the appeal (see [9] to [18] of Citigold (First Instance)).
Land Court accepted a rating period limit but found that minimal monitoring was a mining-related use
In circumstances of ambiguity in interpreting rating categories, the outcome typically ought to be resolved in the ratepayer's favour as set out in [21] of the case of Western Downs Regional Council v Geldard [2020] QLAC 1.
The Appellant argued that the appropriate rating category should turn on the use of the Relevant Land during the rating year, not historical extraction or an indefinite future aspiration to recommence mining.
The Land Court accepted a temporal limit and considered whether the Relevant Land was used, was being used or was intended to be used as a mine within the relevant rating period (see [72] to [76] of Citigold (First Instance)). The Land Court rejected the proposition that holding a mining lease, without more, necessarily establishes use as a mine, as the relevant rating categories in the Revenue Statement require both that a mining lease over land exists and that the land is used as a mine (see [79] to [85] of Citigold (First Instance)).
However, the Land Court held that care and maintenance could constitute a mining-related use, even without extraction despite the Appellant's arguments to the contrary. The Land Court emphasised that some work connected with the mine is necessary and that land left completely idle, without care, security or management, would not ordinarily be in care and maintenance (see [86] to [98] of Citigold (First Instance)).
Despite significant disrepair and flooded workings, the brother of the managing director of the mine kept an intermittent eye on the Relevant Land. The Land Court considered this minimal monitoring sufficient to establish some activity directed towards preserving the mine for possible reopening and found that the Relevant Land was used as a mine during the rating period (see [99] to [107] of Citigold (First Instance)).
Land Appeal Court rejected separate treatment of mining leases for rating purposes
On appeal, the Appellant argued that references to a "mining lease" in the Revenue Statement are singular and that each mining lease should be considered separately.
The Land Appeal Court rejected that construction and applied the principle that the singular includes the plural under section 32C of the Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) (AIA) as it applies to statutory instruments like the Revenue Statement through the Statutory Instruments Act 1992 (Qld) and no contrary intention to section 32C of the AIA are disclosed by the definitions of "mine" and "integrated mining operation" in the Revenue Statement (see [5] to [15] and [23] to [27] of Citigold (Appeal)).
The Land Appeal Court went on to state that such a singular interpretation would be "strained" and there is "…no good reason to infer that the revenue statement contains an intention that…in relation to categories 20 and 21, the singular does not include the plural" (see [25] to [27] of Citigold (Appeal)).
The Land Appeal Court placed particular weight on the statutory valuation framework in the Land Valuation Act 2010 (Qld) and in particular section 30 (Mining leases) and section 57 (Adjoining lots—general) for valuing mining land. There was no separate statutory valuation for each lease against which the $14,999 Category 20 threshold could be tested, and a ratepayer can not assign an independent valuation to rateable land to secure a different category (see [17] to [23] of Citigold (Appeal)).
At first instance, the Land Court found that each parcel of the Relevant Land exceeded the valuation threshold for Category 20 and that the evidence established at least one employee and four consultants, satisfying the fewer than 25 worker criterion (see [109] to [113] of Citigold (First Instance)). The Land Appeal Court's reasons focused on the singular or plural construction and mining use, rather than revisiting the worker finding (at [5] of Citigold (Appeal)).
Mining use extends beyond extraction to rehabilitation planning and steps towards recommencement
The Appellant maintained that the Revenue Statement requires actual mining, in the sense of extracting material from the ground. The Land Appeal Court rejected that restrictive approach and held that the examples of ancillary activities in the "mine" definition are not exhaustive, having regard to section 14D of the AIA (see [30] to [33] of Citigold (Appeal)).
Environmental approvals, mine planning, progressive rehabilitation, closure plans and investigations needed before extraction can resume may be ancillary to, or integral parts of, mining. The Land Appeal Court rejected the Appellant's attempt to treat those regulatory and preparatory steps as irrelevant paperwork (see [34] and [35] of Citigold (Appeal)).
Importantly, the Land Appeal Court did not need to determine whether the occasional site monitoring, by itself, is enough to constitute care and maintenance and therefore satisfy the use of the Relevant Land as a mine. It considered that point moot because the Appellant had prepared a progressive rehabilitation and closure plan during the rating year and publicly stated its intention to restart the mine (at [36] to [38] of Citigold (Appeal)).
The Land Appeal Court found that the Appellant had never abandoned its intention to reopen the mine. Although appropriate finance and dewatering were needed, the Appellant intended to commence preparations once suitable funding became available. Such preparatory work, including dewatering, is ancillary to mining (see [38] to [40] of Citigold (Appeal)).
Unsuccessful commercial appeal attracted costs despite raising a matter of principle
In Citigold (Costs), the Council sought recovery of its costs following its successful defence of the rating appeal in the Land Court. The Appellant contended that the proceeding raised a point of principle and had effectively clarified the Revenue Statement such that each party should bear its own costs (see [8] to [10], [19] to [25] and [42] to [48] of Citigold (Costs)).
The Land Court applied section 27A of the Land Court Act 2000 (Qld). The discretion to award costs is broad, and if no order is made each party bears its own costs. The principle that costs ordinarily follow the event nevertheless informs the judicial exercise of that discretion (see [10] to [18] of Citigold (Costs)).
Although the Land Court accepted that a matter of principle had emerged concerning whether a care and maintenance activity could amount to a mining use, the proceedings were not brought as a test case as submitted by the Appellant nor were proceedings brought to determine a matter of principle despite one being engaged in the case (at [48] of Citigold (Costs)). The Appellant pursued the appeal for its own commercial benefit, which could have reduced its payable rates for the rating period by approximately 55%, and the Council had defended its decision appropriately (see [9] and [42] to [48] of Citigold (Costs)).
The Land Court ordered the Appellant to pay the Council's costs of and incidental to the original rating appeal on the standard basis at the District Court scale (at [49] of Citigold (Costs)). The decision in Citigold (Appeal) contains no separate, detailed analysis of that costs ground. The Land Appeal Court dismissed the appeal and directed that the Appellant pay the Council's appeal costs.
Conclusion
The Appellant was unsuccessful in securing a decision in the Land Court and the Land Appeal Court that changes the mining rating category determined for the Relevant Land which would have the consequence of reducing the rates for the rating period for the reason that the Relevant Land was used as a mine and met the criteria in Category 20 (Other Mine/quarry or extractive land use - less than 25 employees and/or contractors). The Council was successful and awarded costs in both proceedings.
Key points
The Land Court and Land Appeal Court decisions confirm that a local government may categorise non-producing mining land by reference to actual mining-related activity beyond extraction, including monitoring, mine planning and preparations for recommencement, where the particular applicable rating categories support that construction.
For local governments and ratepayers, the decisive inquiry remains in the language of the applicable rating categories and evidence of the land's use. An inactive mine is not automatically outside a mining differential rating category, and an unsuccessful commercial challenge may expose the ratepayer to an adverse costs order.