PUBLICATIONS circle 19 Nov 2026

Bullying, risk and responsibility: When schools need to act

By Megan Kavanagh and Leanne Dearlove

Bullying in schools can extend beyond student behaviour and wellbeing, engaging broader legal, safeguarding and governance responsibilities. Schools should take a risk-based approach to identifying escalating patterns of harm and determining when further intervention is required.


In brief

Bullying is often first encountered as a student wellbeing or behaviour issue. But when conduct persists, moves online, affects a student's psychological wellbeing or involves staff conduct, the issue can quickly extend beyond student wellbeing and behaviour into a broader legal and governance issue.

For schools, the challenge is not simply determining whether particular behaviour fits a definition of bullying. The more important question is: What risk is the school aware of, and what should it reasonably do in response?

That distinction matters because a school's response to bullying can engage its duty of care, work health and safety obligations, child safety framework, complaints processes and, in some circumstances, external reporting obligations.

Bullying: More than a behaviour management issue

Schools owe students a duty to take reasonable care to protect them from reasonably foreseeable harm. That includes harm caused by other students.

Importantly, the duty is not necessarily confined to conduct occurring in the classroom or even within the school gates. Depending on what the school knows about the risk, responsibility may extend to conduct before or after school and, in appropriate circumstances, off-campus behaviour.

This is particularly relevant to cyberbullying. A message may be sent at home, but it can have consequences that extend directly into the school environment. Schools should therefore be cautious about treating conduct as outside their responsibility simply because it occurred online or away from campus. The better question is whether the conduct creates a reasonably foreseeable risk to a student which the school has the capacity to address.

Watch the trajectory, not just the individual incident

Bullying matters are rarely notified in a fully formed way. They may begin with friendship difficulties, exclusion or an isolated comment. They can then progress to group messaging, repeated humiliation, social isolation, school refusal, anxiety or other signs of deteriorating wellbeing.

Each incident considered separately may appear relatively minor. However, when the silos are removed and the conduct is considered holistically, you may find an escalating pattern of risk.

That is why risk assessment should be central to the school's response.

A useful assessment considers:

  • the likelihood that the conduct or harm will continue;
  • the seriousness of the potential consequences;
  • what the school knows, or reasonably ought to know, about the risk;
  • the vulnerability and circumstances of the students involved;
  • the measures available to eliminate or reduce the risk; and
  • whether existing controls are working effectively.

The assessment should also be dynamic. A response that was reasonable when the school first became aware of friendship conflict may no longer be sufficient if the behaviour becomes repeated, moves online or begins to affect a student's mental health.

A practical response framework

When a bullying concern arises, school leaders can work through seven questions:

  1. Concern raised: What precisely has been reported, by whom and when?
  2. Consider reporting obligations: Does the information engage any internal or external reporting requirement?
  3. Assess risk: How likely is further harm, how serious could it be and how urgently must the school act?
  4. Inform the right people: Who needs to know, who should manage the response and when should parents/guardians or others be informed?
  5. Investigate appropriately: What happened and what evidence is available?
  6. Provide procedural fairness: Have relevant students or staff been told the substance of the concerns and given an appropriate opportunity to respond?
  7. Reach a proportionate outcome: Does the response address the conduct, protect those involved and reduce the prospect of recurrence?

This helps avoid two common mistakes: under-reacting to an escalating pattern and over-reacting to an allegation before the facts have been properly established.

What if staff conduct becomes part of the problem?

A bullying matter can also change character when an employee becomes involved. A teacher attempting to manage difficult peer behaviour may themselves become the subject of allegations concerning humiliation, inappropriate discipline, physical intervention or other treatment of a student.

In Queensland, that should prompt schools to consider the Child Safe Organisations Act 2024 (Qld)  and the Reportable Conduct Scheme. The scheme applies to worker conduct and includes categories such as ill-treatment, physical violence and significant emotional or psychological harm. 

The important point is that schools should not wait until an allegation has been proven before considering their reporting obligations. The statutory framework uses a reasonable belief threshold for a reportable allegation, rather than requiring the organisation first to substantiate the conduct.

Equally, not every difficult interaction between a teacher and student will amount to reportable conduct. The legislation recognises conduct that is reasonable for the discipline, management or care of a child, having regard to matters including the child's characteristics and applicable professional standards.

The task for schools is therefore to recognise when an ordinary behaviour-management issue may have crossed into a safeguarding issue and escalate it appropriately.

The governance question: Are our systems working?

For principals, executives and boards, individual bullying complaints can provide important information about the effectiveness of the school's broader systems.

Recurring or escalating complaints should prompt questions such as:

  • Are students confident about reporting concerns?
  • Are complaints being recorded consistently?
  • Are repeated incidents being identified as a pattern rather than treated in isolation?
  • Are risk assessments undertaken and revisited when circumstances change?
  • Are parents/guardians being kept appropriately informed?
  • Do staff understand when a student behaviour issue may engage child safety or reportable conduct obligations?
  • Are policies reflected in practice?
  • Can the school demonstrate why its response was reasonable?

This reflects the broader obligation identified in the workshop material to maintain accessible and timely complaint processes, support affected parties, record and monitor incidents, provide appropriate education and training and take action when concerns are substantiated.

From reactive complaints management to prevention

The goal should not be to create increasingly complex processes around every playground disagreement.

It is to develop a proportionate system that can recognise when the risk has changed.

The strongest safeguarding cultures do not depend on one person recognising the significance of one incident. They create systems in which information is recorded, patterns become visible, risks are reassessed and concerns are escalated when necessary.

For school leaders, the lesson is straightforward:

Consider not only, "Is this bullying?", but ask, "What is the risk now, what do we know about it and what do we reasonably need to do next?"

That shift in thinking can make the difference between simply responding to an incident and preventing an escalating pattern of harm.

For guidance on strengthening your school's approach to bullying and safeguarding risks, contact our Education team.

This is commentary published by Colin Biggers & Paisley for general information purposes only. Cases referenced in this article are reported for information purposes only. Nothing in this article should be taken to imply that any referenced allegation is true or any finding final. This should not be relied on as specific advice. You should seek your own legal and other advice for any question, or for any specific situation or proposal, before making any final decision. The content also is subject to change. A person listed may not be admitted as a lawyer in all States and Territories. Colin Biggers & Paisley, Australia 2026

Stay connected

Connect with us to receive our latest insights.