How long is too long? Managing prolonged employee incapacity in schools
Prolonged employee absence can present difficult legal and operational challenges for schools. We examine the key considerations when managing incapacity, including medical evidence, inherent requirements, reasonable adjustments and procedural fairness.
In brief
Prolonged employee absence requires schools to balance compassion with operational reality. Students need continuity, critical roles cannot remain vacant indefinitely and other employees cannot be expected to absorb additional duties without limit.
The key issue is not simply how long the employee has been absent. It is whether the school has reliable, current medical evidence about the employee’s capacity to perform the inherent requirements of their substantive role, including with reasonable adjustments, and has followed a fair and well-documented process.
1. The three-month threshold is not a green light
Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), an employer must not dismiss an employee because they are temporarily absent due to illness or injury. In broad terms, that protection applies where the employee provides appropriate evidence and:
- has been absent for less than three consecutive months or less than three months in total over a 12-month period; or
- remains on paid personal leave.
Once the employee has been absent for more than three months in a 12-month period and has exhausted paid personal leave, the temporary absence protection may no longer apply. That does not create an automatic right to terminate. The school must still consider unfair dismissal, general protections, discrimination, workers’ compensation and contractual or industrial instrument risks, noting that under WorkCover in some jurisdictions an employee might have a right to reinstatement if they have been terminated within 12 months of an injury.
2. Start with the right medical evidence
A medical certificate stating only that an employee is “unfit for work” or has a “medical condition” is rarely enough to support a long-term employment decision. Depending on the circumstances, the school can reasonably ask the employee to obtain a report from their treating practitioner, seek information from that practitioner with consent or direct the employee to attend an independent medical examination.
Any direction to attend an independent medical examination must be lawful and reasonable. Relevant factors include the medical information already available, the length and pattern of absence, the requirements of the role and any genuine concerns about capacity or safety.
The practitioner should receive an accurate description of the substantive role and be asked targeted questions about:
- current capacity and functional restrictions;
- prognosis and likely treatment;
- whether the employee can perform the role’s inherent requirements;
- adjustments that may enable a return; and
- the timeframe for a return to full duties.
In Daunis v Rivercity Ferries Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 740, the Fair Work Commission upheld the dismissal of a ferry customer service operator who had been absent for 114 days in a 12-month period. The employer relied on three independent medical assessments. While a return to work following further treatment remained possible, there was no clear timeframe for resuming full duties and the proposed reduced hours and modified duties were not operationally workable.
The practical lesson is simple: ask the medical questions needed to make the employment decision. A general statement that an employee is “fit” or “unfit” is of limited value unless it addresses the actual duties, restrictions, prognosis and prospects of returning to the substantive role.
3. Identify the role’s inherent requirements
The medical evidence must be assessed against the inherent requirements of the employee’s substantive role. For a classroom teacher or any role in a school, those requirements can be difficult to describe if they are not already defined in a position description specific to the role. Where position descriptions are generic (or non-existent), it is harder to describe what is required in the role to determine if an employee can meet the inherent requirements.
To be of most use, position descriptions should go beyond the qualifications required to the work that must be done, including delivering face-to-face lessons, planning with colleagues, marking, supervising students and undertaking other duties like yard and after-school duties, attending extracurricular activities, including offsite activities, sport, camps, managing classroom behaviour and maintaining reliable attendance. Even this list may be a bit generic. Ideally a position description should describe the ordinary and extraordinary parts of a role.
That said, not every duty or task in a position description is necessarily an inherent requirement. The focus is on what is genuinely essential. In J Boag & Son Brewing Pty Ltd v Button [2010] FWAFB 4022, the Full Bench confirmed that an incapacity assessment concerns the employee’s substantive position, not modified duties or a temporary alternative role.
4. Reassess if the medical picture changes
An employee may initially stop work because of surgery, injury or another physical condition and later develop anxiety, depression or another psychological condition. If the medical picture changes, the school should not rely on earlier assessments. It should obtain updated evidence addressing the combined effect of all relevant conditions, current restrictions, prognosis, treatment and the timeframe for returning to the substantive role.
The school should also reconsider whether temporary supports, such as a graduated return or reduced hours, would enable the employee to perform the inherent requirements. Under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), the assessment of capacity includes consideration of reasonable adjustments.
5. Keep workers’ compensation and workplace rights separate
Where the condition is work-related, the school should check the applicable workers’ compensation legislation before moving towards termination, including any restrictions on dismissal and ongoing rehabilitation or return-to-work obligations.
The incapacity decision should remain separate from the employee’s workers’ compensation claim, complaints or other workplace rights. The decision-maker should be able to identify the medical evidence relied on, the inherent requirements the employee cannot perform, the adjustments and redeployment options considered and the operational reasons why the position cannot remain unfilled or temporarily covered.
Totino v Metro Trains Melbourne Pty Ltd [2026] FCAFC 120 illustrates the importance of this separation. The Full Court accepted that the relevant decision-makers acted because of the employee’s medical incapacity and the operational need to fill a senior role permanently, rather than because she had exercised workplace rights. The case also reinforces the value of identifying the actual decision-maker, preserving clear evidence of their reasons and providing a genuine show cause process.
6. Consider adjustments and genuine redeployment
Before making a final decision, the school should consider whether reasonable adjustments would enable the employee to perform the inherent requirements of their role and whether further independent medical evidence might be necessary to inform a graduated return, modified hours, workplace supports or changes to duties that are not essential.
There is an important distinction between adjusting how a role is performed and removing an inherent requirement altogether. Any proposal should be tested against the medical evidence and whether it is reasonably workable in the school’s operational context.
The school should also identify genuine and suitable redeployment opportunities. The question is not whether a hypothetical position could be created, but whether an available role provides a realistic alternative to termination.
7. Knowing when to draw the line
There is no single period of absence after which an incapacity dismissal becomes safe. Before deciding whether continued employment remains viable, the school should be able to answer five questions:
- What are the inherent requirements of the employee’s substantive role?
- What does the current medical evidence say about capacity, restrictions and prognosis?
- Is there a realistic prospect of returning to the substantive role within a reasonably foreseeable period?
- Would reasonable adjustments or a genuine redeployment opportunity change the position?
- Can the school clearly demonstrate the decision-maker’s reasons and the fairness of the process?
If those questions cannot be answered, further information may be needed. If they can, the school is in a much stronger position to make a defensible decision.
8. Key takeaways for schools
Before making an incapacity-based decision, schools should:
- obtain current and sufficiently detailed medical evidence;
- identify the inherent requirements of the substantive role;
- ensure all conditions affecting capacity have been assessed;
- consider reasonable adjustments and genuine redeployment opportunities;
- check workers’ compensation, general protections, discrimination and industrial instrument obligations;
- identify the decision-maker and document their reasons; and
- give the employee a genuine opportunity to respond before a final decision is made.
There may never be absolute certainty about whether or when an employee will recover. The goal is not to wait for certainty. It is to reach the point where the school has reliable medical evidence, has genuinely considered available alternatives, has followed a fair process and can clearly explain why its decision is justified.
Conclusion
If your school is managing a prolonged employee absence or considering an incapacity-based termination, please contact a member of our Education team to discuss the issues raised in this article and obtain advice on managing the process.