Public infrastructure wars: New South Wales school development is not an opportunity to resolve existing infrastructure deficiencies
By Todd Neal and Rebecca Pellizzon
A school development application does not necessarily give a consent authority an opportunity to make the school fund longstanding public infrastructure deficiencies.
In brief
The case of Christian Education Ministries Pty Ltd v Singleton Council [2026] NSWLEC 1646 (CEM v Singleton) concerned an appeal to the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales (Court) against the refusal of a development application for the expansion of an existing school at Singleton in New South Wales (NSW).
The Court considered whether Singleton Council (Council) could require an interim student cap, additional parking before enrolments increased and a public intersection upgrade. It approved the application without the disputed conditions, finding that the existing consent already permitted increased enrolments and that the intersection upgrade lacked a sufficient nexus to the proposed development.
School redevelopment
School redevelopment can expose existing operations to demands for infrastructure upgrades. Independent schools across Australia continue to change shape following the pandemic. Growing enrolments, new teaching models, ageing facilities and changing community needs often require schools to expand, redevelop or intensify the use of an established school site. This is happening in urban and regional areas.
School projects can, however, create a particular legal risk under town planning legislation. Once a school lodges a development application, consent authorities sometimes seek to impose caps on student numbers or address broader infrastructure issues around the site, including traffic congestion, intersection capacity, parking or deficiencies in the surrounding road network.
These infrastructure works can be costly.
The difficulty is that those problems may have existed for years. They may arise from broader community demand or inadequate infrastructure investment by local or State governments, rather than the development for which approval is sought.
Parents of independent school students contribute school fees, and schools need to steward those fees to best provide for the school's needs. Without proper advice, schools may feel they have no choice but to accept a cap or pay for large infrastructure upgrades if they want to carry out the proposed development.
However, the law is clear. A school's development application does not necessarily lead to the school becoming responsible for solving wider public infrastructure problems.
Reminder of the limits of consent authorities
CEM v Singleton serves as an important reminder of the limits consent authorities face in leveraging a school's development application to extract broader contributions for public infrastructure.
It provides important lessons for schools contemplating redevelopment, expansion and increased enrolments, particularly where the school already operates under an existing development consent.
School expansion brought three disputed traffic and parking conditions before the Court. The case concerned a proposed expansion of the Australian Christian College at Singleton, including a new classroom building, parking and access works and a cap of 665 students.
The development application was refused, and the applicant appealed against that refusal.
By the hearing, the parties agreed that consent could be granted and most conditions were settled.
The remaining dispute concerned the following proposed conditions:
- A temporary cap of 420 students until the Singleton Bypass became operational.
- Construction of a formal channelised right-hand turn lane at the New England Highway and Kelso Street intersection.
- Construction of a Stage one car park before enrolments exceeded 420.
New consent conditions must relate to the development requiring approval
An important legal issue we often see for any established school is to distinguish between:
- activities or uses already lawfully permitted under existing approvals; and
- the additional development or intensification proposed for which new consent is actually required.
Distinguishing between these is important for numerous reasons, but relevantly here because a new development application does not necessarily reopen every aspect of an existing school's operations to more onerous regulation or provide an opportunity for extracting a contribution towards the upgrade of local infrastructure surrounding the school.
CEM v Singleton provides useful guidance on two recurring questions facing schools during the development assessment process, whether for State significant development or local development under NSW planning laws:
- whether a new consent can be used to re-regulate an activity already authorised by an existing approval; and
- when an applicant can be required to fund public infrastructure works.
The Court answered both questions narrowly.
Although law and practice sometimes diverge, under NSW planning law a consent authority must look at what the application actually needs approval for and what has been applied for. Any condition must fairly and reasonably relate to that development.
A consent authority such as a council cannot necessarily use a new application to impose new controls on an existing lawful use or make an applicant fix a longstanding public infrastructure problem simply because the development will contribute something to that demand.
The decision confirms that additional use of deficient infrastructure does not, of itself, establish a sufficient nexus to require one applicant to fund an upgrade to local or State infrastructure.
Existing consent prevented an interim cap on otherwise lawful student enrolments
The difficulty for Council was that the school's existing consent did not impose a student cap. The Court accepted that enrolments could lawfully increase within the existing buildings independently of the proposed new classrooms.
The Court found that it could not "…assume jurisdiction…" over student numbers independently of the new classrooms (at [39]). References to increased enrolments in the development application did not surrender the benefit of the existing consent or mean that fresh approval was required for an increase already lawfully permitted (see [41] and [44]).
Whilst the school was successful, the controversy serves as a reminder that where an established school proposes new classrooms, sporting facilities, administration buildings or other works, the application should clearly identify:
- what work requires development consent;
- what activities are already authorised by existing consents;
- whether existing approvals impose an enrolment or operational limit;
- the relationship between the new works and any proposed increase in student or staff numbers; and
- which impacts genuinely arise from the proposed development, as opposed to the existing school.
Loose language within the application and supporting reports describing the project as an overall "expansion" or "increase in enrolments" may encourage a consent authority to treat the application as reopening the entirety of the school's operations.
The application, supporting reports and environmental assessment should therefore be carefully aligned with the school's existing approval framework.
New approval could not require parking to remedy an already lawful enrolment increase
Council also sought to require construction of additional parking before enrolments exceeded 420 students. The traffic experts even agreed that 490 students and 51 staff would exceed the existing formal parking capacity.
Nevertheless, because the increase in enrolment was already permissible under the existing consent, the Court concluded that the new approval could not be used to "…retrofit new parking supply to a lawful increase in student numbers." (at [44]).
The Court considered that the existing grassed overflow parking could safely accommodate the increase, and the school proposed staged additional parking on occupation of the new classrooms (see [44] and [45]).
This does not mean that traffic and parking impacts can be ignored. A new development must still demonstrate that its actual impacts are acceptable and can properly be mitigated.
The important point is the nexus. A condition imposed on a new development must relate sufficiently to that development. It may not be able to be imposed to remedy an existing issue associated with an established lawful use.
Intersection upgrade lacked a sufficient nexus to the proposed school development
Council also sought to require the school to fund and construct a formal channelised right-hand turn lane at an intersection with the New England Highway.
The critical evidence was that the traffic experts agreed it was warranted even without the school's proposed development. General traffic volumes and a longstanding public road deficiency created this need.
The Court found that there was not a sufficient nexus between the proposed development and the intersection upgrade condition (at [67]).
This is particularly important for established schools. A development may add traffic to an already deficient intersection or road network without being the cause of the deficiency or creating the need for an upgrade.
Where infrastructure is already inadequate and an upgrade is required irrespective of the school development, requiring one school to fund that upgrade may go beyond what can lawfully or reasonably be imposed as a condition of its consent.
Schools should distinguish existing lawful operations from the impacts of new works
For schools considering major capital works, the key question should be asked early: what impacts are genuinely caused by the development requiring approval, and what problems would exist anyway?
Answering that question requires a clear understanding of what the school can already lawfully do. The application should then separate existing lawful operations from the proposed new development requiring approval and identify the impacts of that development.
Conclusion
CEM v Singleton illustrates that a consent authority can require reasonable measures to address the genuine impacts of a school's proposed development. However, a new development application does not necessarily permit it to rewrite existing lawful entitlements or make the school responsible for a public infrastructure problem that exists independently of its proposal.
Key points
The following key matters are significant for schools considering development:
- Existing approvals should be reviewed to identify lawful enrolment and operational entitlements before a new development application is prepared.
- Applications and supporting reports should distinguish existing lawful operations from the proposed development and its impacts.
- Conditions requiring parking or public infrastructure works must have a sufficient nexus to the development requiring approval.
- An infrastructure deficiency that exists independently of the proposal does not necessarily justify requiring the school to fund an upgrade.