Are you ready for a visit from the safety regulator? A simple process for minimising the risk of notices and/or prosecution
Safety regulators are increasingly investigating psychosocial hazards, creating new risks for businesses unfamiliar with regulatory scrutiny. Understanding how to respond to workplace incidents and investigations can help PCBUs meet their WHS obligations and minimise regulatory and legal risk.
In brief
Workplace incidents and complaints can trigger a safety regulator investigation with little or no warning. PCBUs can take practical steps to manage their response and minimise the risk of notices or prosecution.
What can trigger a visit?
Before psychosocial hazards legislation started to commence across Australian jurisdictions in May 2021, safety regulators almost solely focused on physical hazards when investigating and prosecuting persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs) and other duty holders under the relevant work health & safety (WHS) legislation. As a result, businesses with minimal physical hazards (e.g. white-collar industries) have often had little or no interaction with safety regulators and understandably lack experience in managing and responding to investigations by such regulators. That lack of experience consequently poses significant risks for PCBUs to create and/or provide information and documentation that may significantly increase the risk of notices and/or prosecution, in circumstances where a few simple steps can significantly reduce this risk.
Safety regulators typically commence an investigation as a result of the PCBU notifying the regulator that there has been a notifiable incident, or a complaint being made to the regulator by some other person (for example, a staff member, subcontractor, or client). Depending on the WHS legislation that applies to the PCBU, incidents will ordinarily be notifiable when there has been a death, serious injury or illness, or a dangerous incident (which are typically listed in the relevant legislation). If the PCBU is required to notify the safety regulator of a notifiable incident, they will be aware of the risk that the regulator will attend the workplace and investigate. However, a PCBU will ordinarily receive no notice of a complaint that has been made by some other person and will instead receive a phone call or visit without any warning.
Since the introduction of legislation regarding psychosocial hazards, we have seen a significant rise in the number of complaints made to safety regulators and a significant increase in the number of investigations that relate to psychosocial hazards. By way of example, clients have been subject to investigation as a result of allegations regarding bullying, fear of reprisal, inappropriate sexual relationships, workplace aggression and violence, sexual harassment, high job demands, poor organisational change management, and poor organisational justice. It is also becoming more common for safety regulators to investigate instances of suicide and self-harm, even where such harm occurs outside the workplace.
Recently, we have also noted a substantial increase in the number of staff or former staff who are making complaints to safety regulators in conjunction with other proceedings they have commenced or complaints they have made, including employment proceedings (for example, general protections, unfair dismissal, and discrimination claims), workers compensation claims, whistleblower complaints, and complaints to another regulator, statutory body, or association.
What are the common mistakes?
Ensure any investigation is covered by legal professional privilege
One of the most common mistakes that PCBUs make is to conduct an investigation following an incident or receipt of allegations without first ensuring that the investigation is covered by legal professional privilege (LPP). The reason this first step is critical is that safety regulators have powers to compel the production of information and documentation, as compared to police investigations where witnesses have the right to remain silent. Consequently, PCBUs or other duty holders (i.e. officers or workers) are required to provide any information or documentation that is formally requested by the safety regulator, regardless of whether it may incriminate the PCBU and/or other duty holders. However, a PCBU or other duty holder cannot be compelled to provide any information or documentation that is covered by LPP.
In circumstances where the investigation is covered by LPP, that coverage will extend to all information obtained, such as witness interviews, and will also apply to the final investigation report. This ensures that the investigation can be conducted without fear of disclosure, enabling the investigator to critically analyse the evidence, make findings, and provide any appropriate recommendations. If the investigation is ultimately deemed to be of assistance to the PCBU, it can always be provided to the safety regulator. However, please note that such disclosure will break LPP protection over any information or documentation obtained as part of the investigation, not just the investigation report.
For the avoidance of doubt, a law firm or lawyer does not need to investigate for the investigation to be covered by LPP. What you do need to ensure is that instructions are provided by a law firm to conduct the investigation before it commences. Any information or documentation created prior to receipt of those instructions will not be protected by LPP, including documents or material that already existed, such as emails, policies, or CCTV, regardless of whether they are obtained and considered as part of the investigation.
Only provide information and documentation where formally required
Under WHS legislation, safety regulators can enter the workplace with or without consent or prior notice and exercise various powers, including the seizure of evidence, taking measurements, conducting tests, and taking photographs and recordings. Duty holders are merely required to provide safety regulators with reasonable help (for example, escorting an inspector around the workplace) and must not hinder or obstruct their investigation, but this does not require the provision of any information other than the person's name and address in most circumstances.
Understandably, PCBUs and other duty holders often think they are being helpful by disclosing information and documentation to a safety regulator when requested in writing or verbally. However, it is important that both the PCBU and other duty holders all understand that they are only required to provide information and/or documentation when it is requested by way of a formal notice in accordance with the relevant WHS legislation.
Importantly, any information provided by an individual under compulsion, whether in writing or during an interview, cannot be used against that individual in any subsequent prosecution. In the case of a PCBU, an officer (for example, a director) will ordinarily be required to provide information on its behalf. While the information can unfortunately be used against the PCBU despite being compelled, it is important that officers and workers are aware of the protection they receive personally when only providing information under compulsion.
Relevantly, a PCBU cannot instruct workers as to whether they should or should not provide information and/or documentation to the safety regulator, but it is appropriate to make them aware of their rights and the risks of providing information voluntarily. It may also be beneficial for a PCBU to arrange separate legal representation for workers in certain circumstances. Ensuring that information and documentation is provided only in response to formal notices also creates a clear record of what has been provided to the safety regulator during their investigation.
It is also important for duty holders to understand that in the event of police involvement, or any other regulator, statutory body, or association, any information or documentation that is provided to that party can subsequently be obtained by the safety regulator. For example, even if information is compelled by way of interview with the safety regulator, provision of any information to the police can be used against the duty holder in subsequent proceedings.
Responding appropriately to notices and interviews
Even when a PCBU or duty holder is compelled to provide information and documentation, it is important to understand that you need only provide the information and documentation that has been requested. Again, there is no need to assist the safety regulator with their investigation or to attempt to justify any actions taken for fear of prosecution by the regulator.
The following simple steps should always be taken when providing information to a safety regulator:
- Ensure you understand the question before answering. If not, seek clarification first.
- Where possible, answer the question directly without providing unnecessary information or explanation. For example: yes, no, I don’t know, or I can’t remember.
- Where the question does not permit a direct answer, it should be short, factual, and avoid speculation.
- Any written response from the PCBU that needs to be signed by an officer should be signed by a director or secretary, as they are automatically deemed to be an officer under WHS legislation.
The following simple steps should always be taken when providing documentation to a safety regulator:
- Ensure the document being sought is clear. If not, seek clarification before responding.
- There is no obligation to provide a document that is not in the PCBU or other duty holder's possession or control.
- There is no need to create a document that does not exist, even if information may exist which could be collated into a document that responds to the request.
What are the risks of not managing incident response or an investigation appropriately?
First and foremost, successful incident response is intended to ensure compliance with the PCBU's health and safety obligations. Put more simply, it is intended to ensure that both workers and all other persons go home safely each day. It also helps to minimise the risk of any future incidents, which consequently minimises the risk of action by the safety regulator and/or insurance claims (including workers compensation) and maintains the reputation of the PCBU and other relevant duty holders.
Where a PCBU fails to appropriately manage an investigation by a safety regulator, there are a number of potential consequences depending on the relevant WHS legislation, including:
- prosecution (this includes not only the PCBU, but the prosecution of officers and workers) – this may result in a fine and/or conviction, or entry into an enforceable undertaking; and/or
- receipt of a notice, including improvement and prohibition notices – relevantly, compliance with a notice may later be relied on as evidence in a prosecution.
Such regulatory action could also lead to adverse publicity, which may reduce revenue, limit the ability to tender for or obtain new work, or make it difficult to retain or attract staff. A failure to prevent or defend a prosecution, or receipt of a notice without challenging its validity, may also be relevant to a related insurance claim. In the event of a death, there is also the risk of a coronial inquest, which could lead to a subsequent prosecution by the safety regulator.
What process should you follow to minimise risk following an incident?
The following process can be followed in the event of an incident. It can also be adapted to apply to the receipt of allegations and any subsequent investigation by the safety regulator, noting that there will likely not be any requirement to ensure health and safety immediately, preserve the scene, or notify the safety regulator.
Take immediate action to ensure health and safety:
a. make sure the area is safe;
b. administer first aid; and
c. contact emergency services.Notify the PCBU's incident management team.
Secure the area and preserve the incident scene.
Seek legal advice.
Notify any other relevant stakeholders:
a. Includes internal and external stakeholders, for example:
i. leadership team and/or board;
ii. other relevant staff;
iii. public relations firm; and
iv. family of injured person.Notify the safety regulator (if required) and any other relevant regulator, statutory body, or association (if required).
Commence internal or external investigation.
Manage communications with the safety regulator and any other relevant regulator, statutory body, or association. a. Provide assistance and guidance to workers as required, including engagement of separate legal representation if required.
Consider response to any notices received from the safety regulator.
Consider response to the investigation report and implement any corrective actions.
Conclusion
For advice on responding to workplace incidents, managing investigations by safety regulators, and ensuring WHS compliance, please contact our Employment & Safety team.