PUBLICATIONS circle 20 Nov 2026

From reasonable adjustment to defensible decision making: When schools have to make the hard call

By Megan Kavanagh, Leanne Dearlove and Riaan Hanekom

Schools must carefully assess reasonable adjustment requests while balancing inclusion with safety, educational and operational considerations. Clear consultation, informed decision-making and strong documentation can help schools manage discrimination risk and explain their decisions if challenged.


In brief

Our previous article, “Reasonable adjustment: Supporting inclusion and balancing safety”, considers an increasingly important challenge for schools: supporting inclusion while maintaining the safety, wellbeing and educational needs of the wider school community.

But recognising the obligation is only the beginning.

The more difficult question often arises when a school has obtained the relevant information from allied health or other sources, has considered a requested adjustment, has genuinely consulted, trialled adjustments and supports but still needs to make a decision that a student, parent or employee may strongly disagree with.

Can the school say no? Can it impose a condition? Can it maintain a behavioural, attendance or safety requirement? And, if that decision is later challenged as discriminatory, will the school's reasoning withstand scrutiny?

The answer often turns not simply on what the school decided, but how it got there.

A reasonable adjustment request is a process, not a binary choice

One of the traps in considering adjustment requests is to see the request as binary, providing only two choices: accept or reject it. The question is usually more nuanced and includes a process whereby the school identifies:

  • the barrier the student or employee is experiencing;
  • the adjustment being sought and what it is intended to achieve;
  • the available medical, psychological, educational or other information;
  • whether further information is reasonably required;
  • whether the proposed adjustment is practicable and effective;
  • its impact on safety, learning, other students or staff and school operations; and
  • whether another adjustment could address the person's needs if the particular proposal cannot reasonably be implemented.

The endpoint may be that the adjustment request cannot be accommodated. However, that determination should not be the end, but a starting point for further consultation to determine what can be done and whether other alternatives provide the adjustment needed.

Experts and parents will have input, but it is still the school's decision to make

A parent, supporter, advocate or treating practitioner may recommend adjustments to support a student to attend school safely and to support engagement. Adjustments might include additional support and supervision, reduced hours, avoiding particular activities, a modified approach to completing the curriculum or assessment, modified access and supports (including the use of equipment, staff and other measures to provide access) and altered behavioural expectations.

While recommendations are relevant, they do not necessarily determine what the school must do.

The parent and practitioner will have detailed knowledge of the student, but not necessarily about the school, the staff, the resources and what can be done in terms of the curriculum, staffing arrangements, physical environment, supervision requirements, the needs of other students or the practical consequences of the proposed arrangement.

Given the relative contexts, parent and expert information forms part of a school's consultation and consideration about adjustments, but cannot be the determinative or only consideration. Rather, schools should understand why the adjustment has been recommended, identify any aspects that can and cannot safely or reasonably be implemented, consult with staff about the proposal to determine whether it is reasonable and workable and, where appropriate, return to the practitioner with focused questions or consider alternatives which might achieve the underlying objective.

Difficult decisions require better consultation, not more correspondence

Another common difficulty arises when positions around adjustment become entrenched. In such circumstances, the focus can subtly shift from solving the underlying problem to defending each party's position. At that point, a discrimination complaint may become more likely.

Where possible, schools should bring the discussion back to the underlying need: What is the barrier we are trying to remove and is there another practical way of doing so?

To answer the question, the school does not have to concede legitimate safety, educational or operational requirements. However, it does require genuine consideration of alternatives.

Consistency does not mean identical treatment.

Schools are often concerned that making an exception for one student or employee creates a precedent. That is not necessarily so. A reasonable adjustment for a child who needs it simply reflects a school's commitment to inclusion.

Equal treatment and identical treatment are not the same thing.

Applying exactly the same requirement to everybody can itself create discrimination risk where the requirement particularly disadvantages a person because of a protected attribute. Reasonable adjustment is intended to support a child to compete or participate at the same level as their peers.

Reasonable adjustment does not require every rule to be changed.

The important issue is whether the school can explain the relevant individual circumstances, the legitimate requirements it is seeking to maintain and why the particular outcome was reasonable in those circumstances.

Each of these considerations should be backed up by good information, clear consultation with parents, the student and staff, evidence regarding the trial of similar or the same adjustments and the effectiveness of what is already in place. Such records will help you to tell the story of consultation and the reasonableness of adjustment if your decisions are later challenged.

The file should tell the story

This is where effective discrimination risk management becomes critical. Imagine that 12 months after a decision, an external decision-maker reads the school's file to try to determine whether consultation has been reasonable, adjustments have been made and discrimination has (or has not) occurred. To demonstrate the reasonableness of consultation and adjustment, that decision-maker should be able to easily identify:

  1. what was requested by way of adjustment;
  2. why it was requested;
  3. what information the school obtained to assess the request;
  4. what alternatives were considered and why they were discounted or accepted;
  5. what safety, educational or operational concerns were identified;
  6. how the student, family or staff were consulted about the matter; and
  7. why the final decision was made.

If they can identify each of those considerations and how they were made, the school will usually be in a more reasonable position to explain and defend its decision. If such information is not easily identifiable and the file contains only the request and a final letter saying “the school is unable to accommodate this”, reconstructing the consultation and the decision may be considerably more difficult.

That is why contemporaneous documentation and genuine consultation and communication are so important.

Communication is part of the process

A legally defensible decision can still generate an avoidable dispute if the communication lands poorly.

Where a requested adjustment cannot be provided, schools need to find the right words and way to communicate that outcome. If an alternative can be offered, it should be identified. If further information could affect the position, say what information is required and why.

It is important to avoid language that suggests a person's disability or other protected attribute is itself “the problem” or the reason for a decision. The focus should be on the particular requirement, the individual's needs, the available alternatives, legitimate other considerations (including the safety of staff and others) and any constraints within which the school must operate.

Sometimes the answer can still be “no”

Proper consideration of adjustment does not mean every request must ultimately be accepted. There will be circumstances in which the particular adjustment sought cannot reasonably be implemented, including because of legitimate safety, educational or operational considerations. Where schools have consulted well and have good records to demonstrate the reason for the decision, they should not be afraid to make those decisions.

The strongest “no” will be one reached after the school has confirmed an understanding of the request and the reason for it (for example, the gap being bridged or the challenge being met), after they have obtained appropriate information, consulted meaningfully with parents, the student and staff, considered alternatives and documented its reasons.

A “no” answer may still result in disappointment or dispute. However, where communications have been clear and decisions are well informed, schools will be in a better position to explain and ultimately defend such decisions.

A five-question checklist before the decision

Before finalising a response to a request for reasonable adjustment, school leaders should ask:

  1. Have we identified the protected attribute and the potential disadvantage?
  2. Do we understand what the person needs and why?
  3. Have we genuinely considered the proposed adjustment and reasonable alternatives?
  4. Can we objectively explain any safety, educational or operational constraints?
  5. Does our file demonstrate how we reached this decision?

Those questions will not eliminate discrimination complaints. However, they can greatly improve the quality of the underlying decision and the school's ability to explain it if challenged.

Reasonable adjustment is therefore not simply about saying yes or no to a request. Good risk management lies in the quality of the decision-making journey between the request and the outcome.

Conclusion

If your school is managing a complex reasonable adjustment request or would like to strengthen its approach to discrimination risk management, please contact a member of our Education team to discuss the issues raised in this article.

This is commentary published by Colin Biggers & Paisley for general information purposes only. Cases referenced in this article are reported for information purposes only. Nothing in this article should be taken to imply that any referenced allegation is true or any finding final. This should not be relied on as specific advice. You should seek your own legal and other advice for any question, or for any specific situation or proposal, before making any final decision. The content also is subject to change. A person listed may not be admitted as a lawyer in all States and Territories. Colin Biggers & Paisley, Australia 2026

Stay connected

Connect with us to receive our latest insights.